Hats Off to Hollywood: The Philadelphia Story
Duke: Well, Rex, I never thought I'd see the day when I'd sit through a romantic comedy. But here we are, tackling the American Film Institute's top 10 romantic comedies. Today’s pick was The Philadelphia Story. Made in 1940, it stars Katherine Hepburn, Cary Grant, and James Stewart. Now, I don’t know much about romance or comedy, but this film has a reputation. A lot of folks say it’s one of the best of its kind.
Rex: "A classic is a book that has never finished saying what it has to say." The same could be said about a film like The Philadelphia Story. It’s not just a romantic comedy; it’s a sharp commentary on class and love, filled with witty dialogue and impeccable performances. The film follows Tracy Lord (played by Hepburn), a wealthy socialite whose wedding plans are upended by the arrival of her ex-husband (Grant) and a tabloid journalist (Stewart).
Duke: Ah, yes, the good old love triangle. Or maybe a love square, I can't keep track. But I've got to admit, these three had a way with words. Back in my day, we didn’t have all this fast-talking, back-and-forth banter. People said what they meant, and they meant what they said. But Hepburn, Grant, and Stewart sure knew how to throw those lines around. And I reckon that’s why this movie’s still talked about.
Rex: "The pen is mightier than the sword." The dialogue in The Philadelphia Story is one of its strongest points. It's based on a play by Philip Barry, and the screenplay by Donald Ogden Stewart captures that theatrical wit perfectly. The film came out in 1940, during a time when America was on the brink of entering World War II. People were looking for a bit of escapism, a reminder of the lighter, more glamorous side of life. The film also offered a nuanced take on class differences, challenging the rigidity of high society while still maintaining a sense of humor and grace.
Duke: That’s another thing about this movie—lots of talk about class. The Lords are what you’d call high society folks, and they act like it too. Tracy's trying to figure out if she wants to be with someone from her own world or if she’s willing to mix with someone from a different side of the tracks. Now, I’m no fan of these hoity-toity types, but I reckon the movie does a good job showing that they ain’t all bad. Some of ‘em just need to get knocked down a peg or two.
Rex: "It is not titles that honor men, but men that honor titles." The film's message about understanding, humility, and growth is timeless. Tracy Lord starts off as a proud, seemingly untouchable woman but learns about vulnerability and acceptance by the end. The chemistry between Hepburn, Grant, and Stewart is electric. Hepburn was actually at a turning point in her career when this film came out. She had been labeled "box office poison" after a few flops, but The Philadelphia Story revived her status in Hollywood. She not only starred in it but also had the foresight to buy the film rights, ensuring she could choose the cast and director.
Duke: Smart lady, that Hepburn. I’ll give credit where credit’s due. She played her cards right, and this movie did wonders for her. As for me, I found it more tolerable than most. Maybe it’s because the film had some grit beneath all that polish. Sure, it’s got all the glitz and glamour of those fancy parties, but there’s some real meat on these bones. It’s about people trying to figure themselves out, trying to be better.
Rex: "Every dog has his day." And I believe The Philadelphia Story deserves every bit of its acclaim. It's a delightful mix of humor, romance, and social commentary, proving that a film can entertain and enlighten. Even you found something to enjoy in it, Duke!
Duke: Maybe so, Rex, maybe so. But don’t go thinking I’m getting soft. I’m still a cowboy at heart, and I’d take a good Western over a romantic comedy any day. But if you’re gonna twist my arm, I guess I’d recommend The Philadelphia Story for anyone who likes a good laugh and a bit of romance.
Rex: "Life is a journey, not a destination." And on our journey through the AFI’s top 10 romantic comedies, this one was a memorable stop. Until next time, folks, keep your hats on and your remotes ready! See you at the movies!
To buy your own copy (and support this blog) Blu Ray click here DVD click here
Do you have a movie list that you think Duke and Rex should review? Email us your suggestion at beastlybanterblog@gmail.com
About the Authors
Rex, who speaks in maxims, loves every movie and TV show, making him the perfect counterbalance to Duke. Rex is also known for rescuing an armadillo and celebrating both Christmas and Chanukah.
Comments
Post a Comment